Our Team

HHICC is Staff-led and Elder-protected. This means that the staff makes the day-to-day decisions for the church under the leadership of our Lead Pastor. The Elders provide oversight concerning financial matters, staffing, spiritual unity, accountability for the Lead Pastor and prayer for the staff and church.  Our Lead Pastor also serves as an Elder. Our current Elders are Mike Flood, Matt Webster, Steve Donovan, and Scott Smith. If you would like to contact them, email us here.

Our Stewardship Team advises and serves our church through their unique gifts in the areas of finances and facility management. We have a volunteer treasurer, Bill Callihan, who works with our staff and our outsourced bookkeeping services with BELAY SOLUTIONS to give a "second look" to all our financials and to give our team regular reports. We also have volunteers who work with our staff to advise on interior and exterior needs for our entire campus. It is the role of the staff to raise up volunteers, leaders, and teams to do the work of the ministry in our church and community. You can reach out to staff members below by email or by calling our church office at 843.806.3399. Staff extensions are listed below.

Todd is the Lead Pastor and planted HHICC alongside his wife, Cynthia. He enjoys English Premier Soccer (go Liverpool!), the Atlanta Falcons, Atlanta Braves and Georgia Bulldogs. His hobbies are golf, playing soccer and golf with his son, Sean, and visiting his college girl, Sydney in NYC.

Justin Boyter currently oversees 0-18 as well as our young adults. He also serves on our Executive Team overseeing finances and HR in partnership with our Stewardship Team. Justin is a grad of Dallas Theological Seminary. He and his wife Andrea have three children. Justin loves playing basketball and the Tennessee Volunteers.

Cynthia serves as our Creative Director & serves on our Executive Team. She oversees ministry operations, programming, events, & media. She planted HHICC alongside her husband Todd in 2007 and also serves as one of our worship leaders. Cynthia enjoys reading, movies, art, music, and basically anything that has a creative flair! She is involved in the local arts community on HHI as a board member of Hilton Head Dance Theatre & the Island School Council for the Arts and participates as a Music Director in various local theater shows  when she can!  She and her husband Todd have two children.

Josh is our Pastor of Worship and Technical Arts coming alongside our other two worship leaders, Cynthia and Stephanie.  Josh and his wife Amanda have two boys. Josh works with our programming, production, and technical staff team as well as provide pastoral care to our Worship Arts Ministry. Josh is a die-hard Redskins/WFT, Cubs, and Auburn fan (Amanda is an alumni), and he loves golf, tennis, pickleball, jogging, soccer, and basketball.

Stephanie Reed has been a part of our Worship Ministry for over 14 years. Stephanie and her husband Andy have three daughters  (Nicole, Lauren, and Hannah) and have lived on HHI for over 24 years.

Matthew, an avid Steelers fan, is a native of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. His wife, Naomi, originally from England, works for The Hartford.  Matthew joined our staff team in the summer of 2023 & oversees ages newborn to 18 at HHICC. He and Naomi have four children.

Joanne serves part-time with our Island Kidz Ministry coordinating volunteers and curriculum.

Jake serves part-time with our Island Kidz Ministry & HHI Students.

Miriam Robinson is our Community Center receptionist and administrative assistant to our staff. She coordinates our facility usage and is the smiling face you will see during the week to greet you. 

Sirena Wuerfele assists  with our Finance Team and is a virtual staff member with Belay.  She is a graduate of Purdue University and holds a Masters Degree from the University of Michigan. She lives in Hendersonville, NC along with her teen daughter Sadie. Sirena loves cooking, all things Mid Century Modern and cheering on her Boilermakers.

Meredith is a virtual staff member with Belay and serves as our Communications Director working with our Programming and Creative Team at HHICC.  She graduated from Wake Forest University (go Deacs!) and has worked in church communications for over 10 years. Meredith and her husband Nik live in Rockford, Illinois with their three children.